Department of Pathology, Seoul National University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea
© 2015 The Korean Society of Pathologists/The Korean Society for Cytopathology
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/) which permits unrestricted noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Cytology diagnosis | Total |
---|---|
Ductal adenocarcinoma | 53 |
Malignant tumor, unspecifi | 28 |
Neuroendocrine neoplasm | 10 |
Mucinous neoplasm | 2 |
Squamous cell carcinoma | 1 |
Total | 94 |
Categorya | Case No. | Sex | Age (yr) | Location | Cytology diagnosis | Surgical diagnosis | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | False-negative | 1 | F | 70 | Neck | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma |
2 | F | 53 | Uncinate | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
3 | M | 69 | Tail | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
4 | F | 65 | Body | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
5 | M | 76 | Body | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
6 | M | 58 | Head | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
7 | M | 77 | Body | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
8 | M | 76 | Body | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
9 | F | 69 | Neck | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
10 | M | 71 | Body | IFD | IPMN | ||
11 | F | 70 | Main p-duct | IFD | Malignancy, unspecifi | ||
12 | F | 50 | Body | IFD | Neuroendocrine tumor | ||
2 | False-positive | 13 | M | 75 | Body | Suspected carcinoma | Negative for tumor |
14 | M | 75 | Body | Suspected carcinoma | Negative for tumor | ||
15 | M | 60 | Neck | Carcinoma | Negative for tumor | ||
16 | F | 58 | Body | Adenocarcinoma | Negative for tumor | ||
17 | F | 82 | Head | Atypical | Negative for tumor | ||
18 | F | 38 | Body | Atypical | Negative for tumor | ||
False-negative | 19 | M | 57 | Tail | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | |
20 | F | 61 | Uncinate | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
21 | F | 51 | Tail | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
22 | F | 41 | Head | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
23 | M | 77 | Body | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
24 | F | 67 | Head | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
25 | F | 72 | Head | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
26 | M | 57 | Tail | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
27 | F | 73 | Uncinate | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
28 | M | 64 | Body | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
3 | False-positive | 29 | M | 50 | Body | Atypical | Lymphoplasmocytic sclerosing pancreatitis |
30 | F | 60 | Distal part | Atypical | Lymphoplasmocytic sclerosing pancreatitis | ||
False-negative | 31 | M | 76 | Body | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | |
32 | M | 56 | Head | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
33 | M | 61 | Tail | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
34 | F | 58 | Tail | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
35 | F | 70 | Uncinate | Negative for tumor | IPMN |
F, female; IFD, insufficient for diagnosis; M, male; IPMN, intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm.
aDiscrepancy category: 1) Insufficient for diagnosis (cytology specimen of too few cells), 2) Technical targeting error (normal parenchyma or other non-lesion area aspirated), and 3) Misdiagnosis by pathologists.
Cytology diagnosis | Surgical diagnosis | No. of cases | Category | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Negative (35 cases, 18.3%) | Non-neoplastic lesion | 15 | True-negative | |
Benign lesion | 2 | True-negative | ||
Atypical (undetermined) | 2 | Excluded | ||
Malignant neoplasm (n=15) | Ductal adenocarcinoma | 13 | False-negative | |
Neuroendocrine tumor | 1 | |||
IPMN | 1 | |||
Benign lesion (5 cases, 2.6%) | TIFD | 1 | Excluded | |
Non-neoplastic lesion | 0 | True-negative | ||
Benign lesion | 5 | True-negative | ||
Atypical (undetermined) | 0 | Excluded | ||
Malignant neoplasm | 0 | False-negative | ||
Atypical (undetermined) (37 cases, 19.4%) | TIFD | 0 | Excluded | |
Non-neoplastic lesion | 4 | False-positive | ||
Benign lesion | 1 | False-positive | ||
Atypical (undetermined) | 5 | Excluded | ||
Malignant neoplasm (n=24) | Ductal adenocarcinoma | 18 | True positive | |
Neuroendocrine tumor | 2 | |||
IPMN | 2 | |||
Malignant tumor, unspecifi | 2 | |||
Malignant neoplasm (94 cases, 49.2%) | TIFD | 3 | Excluded | |
Non-neoplastic lesion | 4 | False-positive | ||
Benign lesion | 0 | False-positive | ||
Atypical (undetermined) | 9 | Excluded | ||
Malignant neoplasm (n=79) | Ductal adenocarcinoma | 57 | True-positive | |
Neuroendocrine tumor | 10 | |||
Carcinoma | 4 | |||
IPMN | 3 | |||
Solid-pseudopapillary neoplasm | 2 | |||
Mucinous neoplasm | 1 | |||
Malignant mesenchymal tumor | 1 | |||
Metastatic leiomyosarcoma | 1 | |||
Insuffi for diagnosis (20 cases, 10.5%) | TIFD | 2 | Excluded | |
Non-neoplastic lesion | 5 | True-negative | ||
Benign lesion | 1 | True-negative | ||
Atypical (undetermined) | 1 | Excluded | ||
Malignant neoplasm (n=12) | Ductal adenocarcinoma | 10 | False-negative | |
IPMN | 1 | |||
Malignant tumor, unspecifi | 1 | |||
TIFD | 1 | Excluded | ||
Total | 191 |
Cytology diagnosis | Total |
---|---|
Ductal adenocarcinoma | 53 |
Malignant tumor, unspecifi | 28 |
Neuroendocrine neoplasm | 10 |
Mucinous neoplasm | 2 |
Squamous cell carcinoma | 1 |
Total | 94 |
Category | Percentage | Equation |
---|---|---|
TP (103 cases) | 61.7 | N/A |
TN (28 cases) | 16.8 | N/A |
FP (9 cases) | 5.4 | N/A |
FN (27 cases) | 16.1 | N/A |
Diagnostic accuracy | 78.4 | (TP+TN)/(TP+TN+FP+FN) × 100 |
Sensitivity | 79.2 | TP/(TP+FN) × 100 |
Specifi | 75.7 | TN/(TN+FP) × 100 |
Positive predictive value | 92.0 | TP/(TP+FP) |
Negative predictive value | 50.9 | TN/(TN+FN) |
FP rate | 24.3 | FP/(FP+TN) |
FN rate | 11.6 | FN/(TP+FN) |
Category |
Case No. | Sex | Age (yr) | Location | Cytology diagnosis | Surgical diagnosis | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | False-negative | 1 | F | 70 | Neck | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma |
2 | F | 53 | Uncinate | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
3 | M | 69 | Tail | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
4 | F | 65 | Body | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
5 | M | 76 | Body | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
6 | M | 58 | Head | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
7 | M | 77 | Body | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
8 | M | 76 | Body | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
9 | F | 69 | Neck | IFD | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
10 | M | 71 | Body | IFD | IPMN | ||
11 | F | 70 | Main p-duct | IFD | Malignancy, unspecifi | ||
12 | F | 50 | Body | IFD | Neuroendocrine tumor | ||
2 | False-positive | 13 | M | 75 | Body | Suspected carcinoma | Negative for tumor |
14 | M | 75 | Body | Suspected carcinoma | Negative for tumor | ||
15 | M | 60 | Neck | Carcinoma | Negative for tumor | ||
16 | F | 58 | Body | Adenocarcinoma | Negative for tumor | ||
17 | F | 82 | Head | Atypical | Negative for tumor | ||
18 | F | 38 | Body | Atypical | Negative for tumor | ||
False-negative | 19 | M | 57 | Tail | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | |
20 | F | 61 | Uncinate | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
21 | F | 51 | Tail | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
22 | F | 41 | Head | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
23 | M | 77 | Body | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
24 | F | 67 | Head | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
25 | F | 72 | Head | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
26 | M | 57 | Tail | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
27 | F | 73 | Uncinate | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
28 | M | 64 | Body | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
3 | False-positive | 29 | M | 50 | Body | Atypical | Lymphoplasmocytic sclerosing pancreatitis |
30 | F | 60 | Distal part | Atypical | Lymphoplasmocytic sclerosing pancreatitis | ||
False-negative | 31 | M | 76 | Body | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | |
32 | M | 56 | Head | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
33 | M | 61 | Tail | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
34 | F | 58 | Tail | Negative for tumor | Ductal adenocarcinoma | ||
35 | F | 70 | Uncinate | Negative for tumor | IPMN |
TIFD, tissue insufficient for diagnosis; IPMN, intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm.
TP, true positive; TN, true negative; FP, false positive; FN, false negative; N/A, not applicable. Surgically ‘atypical’ (17 cases) and ‘tissue insufficient for diagnosis’ (7 cases) cases are excluded.
F, female; IFD, insufficient for diagnosis; M, male; IPMN, intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm. Discrepancy category: 1) Insufficient for diagnosis (cytology specimen of too few cells), 2) Technical targeting error (normal parenchyma or other non-lesion area aspirated), and 3) Misdiagnosis by pathologists.