Skip Navigation
Skip to contents

JPTM : Journal of Pathology and Translational Medicine


Author index

Page Path
HOME > Articles and issues > Author index
The Korean Breast Pathology Ki-67 Study Group 1 Article
Interobserver Variability of Ki-67 Measurement in Breast Cancer
Yul Ri Chung, Min Hye Jang, So Yeon Park, Gyungyub Gong, Woo-Hee Jung, The Korean Breast Pathology Ki- Study Group
J Pathol Transl Med. 2016;50(2):129-137.   Published online February 15, 2016
  • 8,653 View
  • 101 Download
  • 17 Citations
AbstractAbstract PDF
As measurement of Ki-67 proliferation index is an important part of breast cancer diagnostics, we conducted a multicenter study to examine the degree of concordance in Ki-67 counting and to find factors that lead to its variability. Methods: Thirty observers from thirty different institutions reviewed Ki-67–stained slides of 20 different breast cancers on whole sections and tissue microarray (TMA) by online system. Ten of the 20 breast cancers had hot spots of Ki-67 expression. Each observer scored Ki-67 in two different ways: direct counting (average vs. hot spot method) and categorical estimation. Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) of Ki-67 index was calculated for comparative analysis. Results: For direct counting, ICC of TMA was slightly higher than that of whole sections using average method (0.895 vs 0.858). The ICC of tumors with hot spots was lower than that of tumors without (0.736 vs 0.874). In tumors with hot spots, observers took an additional counting from the hot spot; the ICC of whole sections using hot spot method was still lower than that of TMA (0.737 vs 0.895). In categorical estimation, Ki-67 index showed a wide distribution in some cases. Nevertheless, in tumors with hot spots, the range of distribution in Ki-67 categories was decreased with hot spot method and in TMA platform. Conclusions: Interobserver variability of Ki-67 index for direct counting and categorical estimation was relatively high. Tumors with hot spots showed greater interobserver variability as opposed to those without, and restricting the measurement area yielded lower interobserver variability.


Citations to this article as recorded by  
  • Predictive Value of Ki-67 Index in Evaluating Sporadic Vestibular Schwannoma Recurrence: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
    Kunal Vakharia, Hirotaka Hasegawa, Christopher Graffeo, Mohammad H. A. Noureldine, Salomon Cohen-Cohen, Avital Perry, Matthew L. Carlson, Colin L. W. Driscoll, Maria Peris-Celda, Jamie J. Van Gompel, Michael J. Link
    Journal of Neurological Surgery Part B: Skull Base.2023; 84(02): 119.     CrossRef
  • Venous invasion and lymphatic invasion are correlated with the postoperative prognosis of pancreatic neuroendocrine neoplasm
    Sho Kiritani, Junichi Arita, Yuichiro Mihara, Rihito Nagata, Akihiko Ichida, Yoshikuni Kawaguchi, Takeaki Ishizawa, Nobuhisa Akamatsu, Junichi Kaneko, Kiyoshi Hasegawa
    Surgery.2023; 173(2): 365.     CrossRef
  • Automated Molecular Subtyping of Breast Carcinoma Using Deep Learning Techniques
    S. Niyas, Ramya Bygari, Rachita Naik, Bhavishya Viswanath, Dhananjay Ugwekar, Tojo Mathew, J Kavya, Jyoti R Kini, Jeny Rajan
    IEEE Journal of Translational Engineering in Health and Medicine.2023; 11: 161.     CrossRef
  • Expression of estrogen and progesterone receptors, HER2 protein and Ki-67 proliferation index in breast carcinoma in both tumor tissue and tissue microarray
    UP Hacısalihoğlu, MA Dogan
    Biotechnic & Histochemistry.2022; 97(4): 298.     CrossRef
  • Diffusive Ki67 and vimentin are associated with worse recurrence-free survival of upper tract urothelial carcinoma: A retrospective cohort study from bench to bedside
    Che Hsueh Yang, Wei Chun Weng, Yen Chuan Ou, Yi Sheng Lin, Li Hua Huang, Chin Heng Lu, Tang Yi Tsao, Chao Yu Hsu, Min Che Tung
    Urologic Oncology: Seminars and Original Investigations.2022; 40(3): 109.e21.     CrossRef
  • Should Ki-67 be adopted to select breast cancer patients for treatment with adjuvant abemaciclib?
    P. Tarantino, H.J. Burstein, N.U. Lin, I.E. Krop, E.P. Winer, S.J. Schnitt, E.P. Hamilton, S.A. Hurvitz, H.S. Rugo, G. Curigliano, S.M. Tolaney
    Annals of Oncology.2022; 33(3): 234.     CrossRef
  • A novel deep classifier framework for automated molecular subtyping of breast carcinoma using immunohistochemistry image analysis
    Tojo Mathew, S. Niyas, C.I. Johnpaul, Jyoti R. Kini, Jeny Rajan
    Biomedical Signal Processing and Control.2022; 76: 103657.     CrossRef
  • Deep learning for the standardized classification of Ki-67 in vulva carcinoma: A feasibility study
    Matthias Choschzick, Mariam Alyahiaoui, Alexander Ciritsis, Cristina Rossi, André Gut, Patryk Hejduk, Andreas Boss
    Heliyon.2021; 7(7): e07577.     CrossRef
  • Oncotype DX Predictive Nomogram for Recurrence Score Output: The Novel System ADAPTED01 Based on Quantitative Immunochemistry Analysis
    Fabio Marazzi, Roberto Barone, Valeria Masiello, Valentina Magri, Antonino Mulè, Angela Santoro, Federica Cacciatori, Luca Boldrini, Gianluca Franceschini, Francesca Moschella, Giuseppe Naso, Silverio Tomao, Maria Antonietta Gambacorta, Giovanna Mantini,
    Clinical Breast Cancer.2020; 20(5): e600.     CrossRef
  • Study of Ki-67 index in the molecular subtypes of breast cancer: Inter-observer variability and automated scoring
    Divya Meermira, Meenakshi Swain, Swarnalata Gowrishankar
    Indian Journal of Cancer.2020;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • Improving the accuracy of gastrointestinal neuroendocrine tumor grading with deep learning
    Darshana Govind, Kuang-Yu Jen, Karen Matsukuma, Guofeng Gao, Kristin A. Olson, Dorina Gui, Gregory. E. Wilding, Samuel P. Border, Pinaki Sarder
    Scientific Reports.2020;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • Practical approaches to automated digital image analysis of Ki-67 labeling index in 997 breast carcinomas and causes of discordance with visual assessment
    Ah-Young Kwon, Ha Young Park, Jiyeon Hyeon, Seok Jin Nam, Seok Won Kim, Jeong Eon Lee, Jong-Han Yu, Se Kyung Lee, Soo Youn Cho, Eun Yoon Cho, Irina V. Lebedeva
    PLOS ONE.2019; 14(2): e0212309.     CrossRef
  • Evaluation of Ki-67 Index in Core Needle Biopsies and Matched Breast Cancer Surgical Specimens
    Soomin Ahn, Junghye Lee, Min-Sun Cho, Sanghui Park, Sun Hee Sung
    Archives of Pathology & Laboratory Medicine.2018; 142(3): 364.     CrossRef
  • Assessment of Ki-67 for Predicting Effective Prognosis in Breast Cancer Subtypes
    Sangjung Park, Sunyoung Park, Jungho Kim, Sungwoo Ahn, Kwang Hwa Park, Hyeyoung Lee
    Biomedical Science Letters.2018; 24(1): 9.     CrossRef
  • Quantitative tumor heterogeneity assessment on a nuclear population basis
    Anne-Sofie Wessel Lindberg, Knut Conradsen, Rasmus Larsen, Michael Friis Lippert, Rasmus Røge, Mogens Vyberg
    Cytometry Part A.2017; 91(6): 574.     CrossRef
  • A comparison of Ki-67 counting methods in luminal Breast Cancer: The Average Method vs. the Hot Spot Method
    Min Hye Jang, Hyun Jung Kim, Yul Ri Chung, Yangkyu Lee, So Yeon Park, William B. Coleman
    PLOS ONE.2017; 12(2): e0172031.     CrossRef
  • A Novel Breast Cancer Index for Prediction of Distant Recurrence in HR+ Early-Stage Breast Cancer with One to Three Positive Nodes
    Yi Zhang, Brock E. Schroeder, Piiha-Lotta Jerevall, Amy Ly, Hannah Nolan, Catherine A. Schnabel, Dennis C. Sgroi
    Clinical Cancer Research.2017; 23(23): 7217.     CrossRef

JPTM : Journal of Pathology and Translational Medicine